Expert answer

Hi Clare,

There don't seem to be many of them about so it's difficult to give you an average price as selling prices seem to vary from as low as €500 to nearly €4,000. Somewhere in the middle of those seems sensible to us, but the final price will depend massively on condition, service history, the specification and how badly the buyer wants it.

Sorry not to be more helpful

Expert answer

Hi Margaret,

Both are fantastic cars, but the EV2 definitely has a higher 'hip point', meaning you sit higher up and it's easier to get in and out of it. The Kia is also a fraction more comfortable on the road.

But... if you like the Renault 5, you should really check out the Renault 4 EV as well, as you sit up higher in that and it shares a lot with the 5.

Either way, make sure you go and test drive both cars to get a feel for them - and we'd massively appreciate a (private) message via the Contact Us page to let us know which one you go for.

Expert answer

Hi Jean,

We don't believe anything has changed on that front to help alleviate the situation.

The 12-volt battery in Toyota hybrids is not charged by an alternator turned by the engine as it would be in a traditional petrol engine. Instead, its charge is maintained by the hybrid system itself, via a DC-DC converter, though this is not done particularly quickly – and can only be done when the car is 'running' (even with the engine off, but with 'READY' showing in the instruments).

Unfortunately, during lots of short journeys, with relatively more opening and closing and other drains on the battery, there isn't enough time for the system to keep up with the discharging of the 12-volt battery. This is exacerbated by the fact that these cars use a much smaller-capacity battery than an equivalent petrol car would to start with, so they have a lot less in reserve.

It's not ideal, but the advice is to make sure the cars get a longer run periodically.

Expert answer

Hi Adeniyi,

The VIN you provided doesn't give ue full details unfortunately. We can tell that it's an e-Power hybrid, likely a Japanese import, but nothing else beyond that. 

If it is a Japanese import and the seller cannot give you these figures it may be possible to obtain a Certificate of Conformity from the Japan Inspection Organization, though we've not used the process ourselves. Click on the link to read up on how to do this.

If this is not a Japanese import, come back to us and post a different question to that effect, detailing which variant of the X-Trail it is exactly and where it is coming from.

Expert answer

Hi Tonya,

Unfortunately, you left out the model year, and that's crucial, as we found similarly described cars in the classifieds priced from about €3,000 up to €11,000. Come back to us and let us know the year for a more precise estimate.

Expert answer

Hi Brendan,

Assuming you don't need the bigger boot of the ID.4, then I'd suggest that the Elroq is a superior car in every other way. It drives better, has a far nicer interior and doesn't have the ID.4's ridiculous electric window switches. The Elroq is newer as well in terms of technology and development, so its software and infotainment are better resolved and it's more refined.

The only thing I would say is that the Sportline model may ride on low-profile tyres that detract from comfort a little, so make sure you drive it over poor roads to ensure you're happy with it before you commit.

Drop us a message (in private) via the Contact Us page to let us know how you get on.

Skoda Elroq reviews

Volkswagen ID.4 reviews

Expert answer

Hi Ashley,

In principle, that should work, though Revenue is specifically looking out for people trying to circumvent VAT and import duty on such cars and there is no fixed three-month period. The wording says, “a reasonable amount of time” and that Revenue will take it on a case-by-case basis.

I suspect that, if it saw the name of the person registering the car in Ireland anywhere near the original paperwork in England, it would suggest that VAT and import duty are payable.

VRT should be minimal or zero depending on the value of the EV after importation regardless of where the car is coming from.

Expert answer

Hi Patrick,

No matter what, you'll have to pay VRT on it, usually 13.3 per cent of the Open Market Selling Price (OMSP) for category B vans.

The bigger question is whether VAT and customs duty apply, and that depends entirely on the van's history.

If the van has been registered and in use in Northern Ireland, then you should not have to pay either VAT or customs duty when importing it into the Republic.

However, many vans in Northern Ireland were originally supplied from Great Britain (i.e. England, Scotland or Wales). If that's the case - or if you can't prove the van's use in the North - Revenue may treat it as a GB import via NI, which can trigger 23 per cent VAT and 10 per cent customs duty.

There's also a separate rule for newer vehicles: if the van is less than six months old or has under 6,000km on its clock, Irish VAT will apply regardless of where it comes from.

In summary, VRT is a given, but avoiding VAT and import duty comes down to having clear evidence that the van has been properly in use in Northern Ireland.

Expert answer

Hi Dermot,

Because the car originally came from Great Britain, Revenue will want proof that it was properly imported into Northern Ireland under the Windsor Framework. An invoice isn't enough on its own.

If the dealer can provide the relevant customs or TSS documentation, you should be able to bring it in without VAT. If they can't, Revenue may treat it as a GB import, which could mean 23 per cent VAT and customs duty on top.

In short, you really need that paperwork from the dealer.

Expert answer

Hi Elaine,

Those cars are remarkably well-matched in terms of performance and interior space. They're both comfortable enough on the motorway and easy to drive around town as well. There's very little to choose between them.

While we do prefer the exterior appearance and interior design of the Dacia, the Opel does come with a longer warranty, so if you're planning on keeping the car for a long time that is certainly a factor to consider. Saying that, Dacia's cars are generally quite durable so we'd not be overly worried about it.

For us, the Duster just edges it, so I recommend you take both for as long a test drive as you can, including some motorway driving, to see which you prefer. 

And do us a favour - drop us a (private) message via the Contact Us page to let us know which you go for and why.