Mercedes-Benz A 200 petrol review
A stylish new Mercedes A-Class has arrived in Ireland; can the petrol version take the fight to the Golf?
Shane O' Donoghue
Shane O' Donoghue

Published on August 10, 2018

What are you driving?

The fourth-generation Mercedes-Benz A-Class. It arrived on Irish shores just in time for the '182' registration plate and takes the fight to other premium compact C-segment cars such as the Audi A3, BMW 1 Series, Volkswagen Golf and Volvo V40. Though a stylish four-door A-Class Saloon is due next year, here we test the five-door hatchback. While we expect the range to fill out with more engine options in the coming year, at the time of writing, buyers can choose either the A 180 d (1.5-litre diesel, auto only, starts at €31,600) or the car tested here, the A 200.

The A 200 features a turbocharged 1.3-litre petrol engine, putting out 163hp and 250Nm of torque to the front wheels, either via a standard six-speed manual gearbox or the optional seven-speed dual-clutch automatic tested here. Prices for the A 200 start at €32,040 for the Style version, rising to this car, the range-topping A 200 AMG Line with an automatic transmission.

In between is the Progressive trim level, but the step up in price from that to the AMG Line car seems all but irrelevant given the far more appealing appearance of the latter. Indeed, using the Mercedes PCP product (Star Finance), the difference is less than €20 a month all things being equal. For that, the AMG Line car adds 18-inch alloys, a chunky sport steering wheel trimmed in Nappa leather, an AMG body kit and plenty of other details that enhance the A-Class no end.

Name its best bits

I probably don't need to, as you're possibly too busy drooling over our pictures to read these words in any case. The new A-Class is a cracking looking car, even more so than our images can convey, and the specification of the test car really accentuates that, mixing cool five-spoke alloys with lustrous black paintwork and the optional Night Package (a reasonable €623).

But the exterior design is only a teaser, as this car's USP comes from its cabin. There, potential buyers in a Mercedes showroom will 'squeee' with excitement at the sight of the very impressive looking 'MBUX' multimedia system. This takes the form of one long iPad-ish display, replacing traditional instruments and the infotainment screen in one seamless unit. And it works as well as it looks, with a slick interface through either touch on the screen itself (not the portion in front of the driver...), using the large touchpad on the centre console, activating the impressive voice recognition system by saying "Hey Mercedes!" or, our favourite method, using the little thumbpads on the steering wheel spokes. In one fell swoop it's the best system of its kind on the market. You're waiting for the "but, it costs...", aren't you? Actually, it's standard fit across the range. The rest of the cabin looks good, too, including the distinctly sporty seats.

Anything that bugs you?

It's annoying that there's clearly a good chassis underneath trying to get out, but it feels stymied somewhat. After all, that sharp-suited exterior and flat-bottomed steering wheel raise your expectations. Now, to be clear, it's not a completely duff steer; the chassis feels biddable and agile, it corners flat and isn't as uncomfortable over broken surfaces as you might expect it to be. But neither is it quite as engaging as we'd like. To start with, the steering is rather slow, meaning you have to turn it more than you expect at times, which makes the front-end of the A-Class feel less responsive than you'd like. Saying that, once you have turned in, it is planted and there is a huge amount of grip, though the front and rear react differently to bumps, giving them a disconnected feel that will make you slow down on a badly surfaced road.

I also reckon that the automatic transmission is detracting from the driving experience in this car. While it's very smooth at full-throttle up-shifts, and the gearchange paddles are tactile, left to its own devices it makes some odd decisions, including dropping down a gear or two every time you touch the throttle for a bit of acceleration, even when you're not using the Sport mode. That might be acceptable if a high-revving naturally aspirated engine was under the bonnet, but the turbocharged 1.3-litre unit produces ample torque low down the rev range, so it's actually more satisfying to take over control of the gears for yourself and use that torque rather than listen to the (not particularly sporty) sound of the engine. One thing is for sure: there's loads of performance on tap, but we suspect that the manual gearbox may be a better option for accessing it all in a more satisfying manner.

And why have you given it this rating?

We were verging on a 3.5-star result here, but we have to concede that more people care about the aesthetics, the interior and the technology in a car such as the A-Class than do about how it drives. Those that want a hot hatch will go out and buy one; the Mercedes A 200 isn't that, but for those that are looking for a premium hatchback with good performance, a great image and cutting-edge technology, the new A-Class makes a strong case for itself.


Tech Specs

Model testedMercedes-Benz A 200 AMG Line Automatic
Pricing€41,479 as tested; A-Class starts at €31,600
Engine1.3-litre turbocharged four-cylinder petrol
Transmissionseven-speed dual-clutch automatic, front-wheel drive
Body stylefive-door, five-seat hatchback
CO2 emissions123g/km (Band B1 - €270 per annum)
Combined economy51.4mpg (5.5 litres/100km)
Top speed225km/h
0-100km/h8.0 seconds
Power163hp at 5,500rpm
Torque250Nm at 1,620rpm
Boot space370-1,210 litres
Rivals to the A 200 petrol